Karachi: The Federal Constitutional Court (FCC) has invalidated the provincial infrastructure cess that affected goods moving in and out of the province, primarily impacting the Sindh Infrastructure Development Cess (SIDC) levied on goods passing through Karachi's ports. This decision marks a significant development in a legal battle that has spanned nearly two decades.
According to JS Global, the SIDC was first introduced in 1994 as a 1% fee on the cost and freight value of goods. It was later increased to 1.25% and then to 1.85% as of July 2024. The Sindh High Court had upheld the 2017 Cess Act with retrospective effect in June 2021, but the Supreme Court suspended that ruling in September 2021, allowing goods to be cleared against bank guarantees. Many companies, therefore, maintained full provisions for the cess.
In a move to reduce litigation, Sindh lowered the cess to 0.85% for companies that withdrew their petitions and settled, and to 0.80% for those without litigation. Payments could be made in installments until 2040, prompting some companies to adjust their liabilities and reverse excess provisions.
In the wake of the FCC's ruling, companies are categorized based on their settlement status. Companies like NML, FFC, and SLM, which have not settled, hold SIDC liabilities totaling approximately Rs15.8 billion. These companies are expected to reverse these provisions, positively impacting earnings, with NML and FFC seeing the largest earnings per share (EPS) impacts.
On the other hand, companies such as ENGROH, ISL, and EFERT that have settled are anticipated to reverse remaining provisions worth about Rs21.9 billion. This action will result in notable EPS impacts for several firms, including HCAR and INDU.
The ruling does not directly affect some companies, including oil marketing companies like PSO and APL, as they have not recognized SIDC provisions in their financial statements, thus experiencing no direct earnings impact.