Karachi: The Federation of Pakistan Chambers of Commerce and Industry (FPCCI) has raised concerns over the Federal Board of Revenue's (FBR) decision to separate the collection of sales tax and income tax, arguing that this move could weaken efforts to curb tax evasion and expand the informal economy. The organization's president, Atif Ikram Sheikh, cautioned that this administrative change could burden compliant businesses with increased oversight while leaving tax evaders unchecked.
According to Federation of Pakistan Chambers of Commerce and Industry, Mr. Sheikh highlighted that the unified Inland Revenue administration, which has been in place since 2009, provided a critical mechanism for cross-verification between sales and income tax collections. By dismantling this framework, the ability of authorities to detect discrepancies through integrated oversight might be compromised, potentially stalling efforts to improve Pakistan's tax-to-GDP ratio.
Mr. Saquib Fayyaz Magoon, Senior Vice President of FPCCI, noted that the split could impose dual oversight on compliant manufacturers, importers, and distributors, leading to confusion and inefficiencies. He criticized the approach for potentially subjecting businesses to conflicting interpretations by different tax commissioners, rather than incorporating unregistered sectors into the tax system.
Mr. Abdul Mohamin Khan, Vice President and Regional Chairman Sindh, FPCCI, urged the Ministry of Finance and the FBR to focus on capacity building and integrated data analytics instead of structural fragmentation. He stressed that duplicating administrative layers might increase compliance costs and harassment for formally registered businesses, while failing to address the informal sector.
Additionally, Mr. Asif Sakhi, Vice President of FPCCI, pointed out a disparity in tax collection trends, noting a 1.7 percent decline in domestic sales tax collection compared to a 17 percent increase in import-stage collections. He argued that this situation indicates that the current tax framework disproportionately affects documented trade without effectively broadening the domestic tax base.